Just like breakfast, lunch and dinner, Red Arrow Diner serves dessert 24/7. Original recipes were developed by our very own baker Rachel and each dessert is freshly made in the Red Arrow Diner kitchen. If you would like to order a full pie or cake, be sure to visit our Pie and Cake Order Form.
One-of-a-Kind Eclairs 3.99
Our own recipe, freshly baked at the diner, an definitely better than Twinkies! Pre-order through our Pie and Cake Order Form to guarantee availability!
- One for 1.75
- Six for 8.99
- Twelve for 15.99
Dinah Finger Strawberry Shortcake
A little different – It’s Dinah’s Way!
- Queen 3.50
- King 4.99
Whoopie Pies 3.99
- Chocolate – available everyday
- Red Velvet & Pumpkin – catch them in season only
Assorted Fruit Pies 3.99/slice
Double Layer Cake 3.99/slice
Cream Pies 3.99/slice
A Red Arrow Must!
Dish of Ice Cream 2.50
Includes Whipped Cream, Sprinkles and a Cherry
Ice Cream Toppings: Chocolate, Caramel, Strawberry, Banana, Choose 2 for 3.75, Choose 3 for 4.75, Choose 4 for 5.50
Root Beer Float 4.75
All of our Meat Pies & Dessert Pies are also available to go, by the slice or by the pie! Guarantee to get your desired flavor by ordering in advance by using the Red Arrow Diner Pie and Cake Order Form. You can also view the many available flavors to see what we offer year-round!